Bench vs QuickBooks vs Pilot: Bookkeeping for Freelancers & Independent Creators
As a freelancer or independent creator, your time is money. Do you spend it editing, writing, designing, or dealing with receipts and spreadsheets? This guide helps you pick the right bookkeeping option: Bench, Pilot, or QuickBooks. It's about whether you want to do your own books, or pay someone else to do it so you can focus on your craft. Your choice depends on how much you value those hours away from client work or creating new content.
READY TO TAKE ACTION?
Use the free LaunchAdvisor checklist to track every step in this guide.
The Quick Answer
Bench is the best choice if you're a busy freelancer or creator earning consistent income and you want to completely outsource your books. Think social media managers or photographers who just want a clean report for tax time, without ever logging into accounting software. Pilot is designed for venture-backed tech startups, not typically for independent creators who fund their own work. QuickBooks is for freelancers who want to manage their own expenses, invoices, and income, or work closely with a freelance bookkeeper using the platform. It gives you the most control but also demands the most time from you or your hired help.
Side-by-Side Breakdown
**Bench:** Starts around $299/month (Essential plan). You get a human bookkeeper who understands freelance income and expenses. They handle your cash-basis accounting and give you monthly financial reports, perfect for annual tax filing (especially your Schedule C). This means you won't touch the software yourself. Bench uses its own platform, so it doesn't directly link up with QuickBooks or Xero for you to see. For a freelancer, $299/month is like giving up the profit from one small writing gig or a few hours of design work.
**Pilot:** Starts at $499/month (Starter plan). Pilot is built for startups with complex needs, like attracting investors or managing employee stock options. It uses accrual-basis accounting and offers a dedicated finance team. Frankly, for most individual freelancers or independent creators, this service is likely too much and too expensive. You probably don't have investor reporting, stock options, or complex revenue recognition to worry about.
**QuickBooks Online:** Software plans range from about $35-$235/month. With QuickBooks, you (or a bookkeeper you hire) do all the work. This means you manually track your software subscriptions (like Adobe Creative Cloud or editing tools), project-specific expenses (stock photos, equipment rentals, travel), and client payments. It offers maximum flexibility to customize your charts of accounts (e.g., categories for "Photography Equipment," "Marketing Software," "Client Travel"). It's the industry standard for many CPAs who prepare freelance taxes. The software cost is lower, but remember the time cost if you do it yourself – hours you could be spending on client projects or creating new content.
When to Choose Bench
Choose Bench if you're a freelancer, writer, designer, or creator earning consistent income (say, over $3,000-$5,000 a month) and you absolutely dread dealing with numbers. You're likely operating on a cash-basis (money in, money out) and don't have investors demanding fancy financial reports. You just want someone to handle all your income and expense tracking, then send you clean, organized reports for your annual tax filing – especially those dreaded 1099s. Bench is perfect if you want to completely free up time spent on invoices and receipts, allowing you to focus 100% on client work, creating content, or developing new projects.
When to Choose Pilot
Frankly, most individual freelancers and independent creators will not need Pilot. This service is for high-growth tech startups that have raised funding rounds (like a seed round) or plan to. If you have outside investors, a board of directors, complex revenue streams (like deferred revenue from subscriptions), or equity compensation plans for employees, then Pilot might make sense. These are issues far beyond the scope of a typical freelance business. If you fit this description, you're likely no longer just a "freelancer" but running a full-scale startup.
When to Choose QuickBooks (DIY or with a Bookkeeper)
QuickBooks is a good fit if you are a cost-conscious freelancer or creator who wants to keep a close eye on your finances. This is especially true if you are tech-savvy enough to handle the software yourself, or if you plan to hire a freelance bookkeeper for a few hours a month to manage it for you. You want direct control over how your income from client projects (e.g., photography shoots, writing commissions) and expenses (e.g., camera gear, software subscriptions like Canva Pro or Adobe CC) are categorized. QuickBooks helps you easily separate personal and business expenses, track mileage for client meetings, and send professional invoices. Many freelancers start here because the software cost is manageable, and it’s the standard for tax professionals who will help you file your Schedule C.
The Verdict
For most freelancers and independent creators, the choice boils down to QuickBooks (DIY or with light bookkeeper help) or Bench (fully managed).
**Starting out / Under $5,000/month income:** Use QuickBooks Online Simple Start or Wave (a free alternative) if you're comfortable doing it yourself. Focus on tracking every dollar in and out to get ready for tax season. This is for new writers, designers taking on their first few clients, or photographers building their portfolio.
**Growing Freelancer / $5,000-$10,000+/month income:** If you're a busy freelance social media manager, video editor, or consultant who consistently earns good money and wants more time for client work, Bench is a solid choice. It frees you from the chore of bookkeeping entirely.
**Advanced / Scaling to Agency:** If you pass the $10,000-$15,000/month mark, perhaps hire contractors, or have more complex client contracts, you might stick with QuickBooks and bring in a dedicated freelance bookkeeper for several hours a month. This gives you deeper financial insights without the full cost of a service like Bench.
Pilot remains outside the scope for almost all individual creators unless you're truly building a venture-backed tech company, not just selling your individual skill.
How to Get Started
**Bench:** Visit their website and start a free trial. You'll connect your bank accounts (where your client payments land and expenses come out). Bench typically assigns a dedicated bookkeeper within a couple of business days and can have your first month of books tidied up within two weeks.
**Pilot:** If, by some chance, you are a freelancer scaling into a full-blown tech startup (unlikely, but possible), schedule a scoping call with Pilot. Be ready to discuss your complex revenue streams and investor needs. Budget for a cleanup fee if your previous books are messy.
**QuickBooks:** If you're going the DIY route, start with QuickBooks Online Simple Start. Link your business bank account and credit cards. Use the 30-day free trial to practice categorizing your last 90 days of income (e.g., "Client Payment - Design Project") and expenses (e.g., "Software Subscription - Adobe," "Travel - Client Meeting"). This will give you a good feel for the software before you fully commit.
RECOMMENDED TOOLS
Bench
Managed bookkeeping from $299/month
Pilot
Startup-focused bookkeeping from $499/month
QuickBooks Online
30-day free trial, then from $35/month
Some links above are affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you sign up — at no extra cost to you.
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
Does Bench use QuickBooks?
No. Bench uses its own proprietary platform. This means you cannot export your data directly into QuickBooks if you switch. Plan for a migration project if you outgrow Bench.
Is Pilot worth the price for an early-stage startup?
If you have raised a seed round, yes. Investor reporting, accrual accounting, and audit-readiness are worth more than $500/month when you are managing a round. Pre-seed, the price is hard to justify.
What is the difference between cash-basis and accrual accounting?
Cash-basis records income when cash is received and expenses when paid. Accrual records income when earned and expenses when incurred, regardless of when cash moves. Most businesses under $25M in revenue can use either, but investors and lenders generally prefer accrual.