E-Commerce Pricing Strategy: How to Price Products for Shopify, Etsy & Amazon
Pricing products for your online store, whether it's a new Shopify site, an Etsy shop, or Amazon FBA, is different from selling in a physical store. Your cost of goods, platform fees, shipping expenses, and ad costs interact in ways that can make a product profitable in one channel and lose money in another. Here is how to get the math right before you launch your online business.
READY TO TAKE ACTION?
Use the free LaunchAdvisor checklist to track every step in this guide.
The quick answer for online sellers
Selling directly from your own website (DTC via Shopify, WooCommerce) gives you the highest per-unit margin but means you handle all customer acquisition (ad spend, SEO). Selling on marketplaces like Etsy or Amazon FBA means platform fees and transaction percentages reduce your cut, but they drive traffic for you. Design your pricing from day one to cover these channel-specific costs and leave room for profit, regardless of where you sell.
Online pricing models: Shopify vs. Marketplaces
When pricing your products for online sales, consider two main approaches:
**Marketplace Pricing (e.g., Etsy, Amazon FBA, eBay):** Marketplaces usually take a percentage of the sale (e.g., Etsy's 6.5% transaction fee + $0.20 listing fee, Amazon FBA referral fees often 8-15% depending on category, plus fulfillment and storage fees). Your price needs to be high enough to absorb these platform cuts, payment processing fees (typically 2.9% + $0.30), and still cover your cost of goods (COGS) and desired profit. A general rule for future flexibility: aim for a selling price at least 3-4x your COGS before fees to give yourself breathing room.
**Direct-to-Consumer (DTC) Pricing (e.g., Shopify Store):** You set your retail price directly. While you avoid marketplace fees, you absorb payment processor fees (typically 2.9% + $0.30) and the full cost of customer acquisition (Facebook Ads, Google Shopping, influencer marketing). You also cover shipping costs (USPS First-Class, UPS Ground) and return processing. Your effective margin after ad spend and fulfillment might be lower than it appears on paper, even with higher per-unit revenue.
When to prioritize your own online store (DTC)
Prioritize selling on your own Shopify or WooCommerce store when you have an existing audience (email list, Instagram followers, TikTok community) ready to buy. This is also key when your product benefits from a rich brand story (which marketplace listings often strip away) or requires detailed explanation through videos and unique product pages. DTC margins fund your brand building, allowing you to invest in better content, customer service, and loyalty programs.
When to prioritize marketplaces or wholesale
Prioritize selling on marketplaces like Amazon FBA or Etsy when customer discovery is your primary challenge (their massive user bases act as a discovery engine). These platforms can provide instant visibility you can't generate yourself in the early stages. Also, consider selling wholesale to brick-and-mortar stores or specialty online retailers when your unit economics support the margin reduction (e.g., you need volume to drive down your COGS with suppliers) and their distribution can reach new customer segments.
The verdict for online sellers
Build your cost structure to support pricing that works across multiple channels from day one. Even if you start with your own Shopify store, ensure your price could eventually accommodate marketplace fees or potential wholesale margins without forcing you into the red. Starting DTC allows you to gather real-world margin data and test demand before expanding to platforms or partners with higher commission structures.
How to get started with your e-commerce pricing
First, calculate your 'landed cost per unit.' This includes materials, production labor, packaging (custom boxes, poly mailers, tissue paper), and inbound shipping to your fulfillment location. Now, multiply that landed cost by 3 to 4. This target price should cover your COGS, all online selling fees (platform, payment processing, shipping labels), ad spend, and still leave a healthy profit. If this target price is competitive with similar products in your niche, you have a viable product. If it's too high, you need to find ways to reduce your COGS before you even think about setting your final retail price.
RECOMMENDED TOOLS
Shopify
Launch your DTC store and manage both wholesale and retail channels
Wave
Track product costs and margins from day one at no cost
QuickBooks
Inventory tracking and COGS management as you scale
Some links above are affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you sign up — at no extra cost to you.
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
Do I need different pricing for Amazon vs my own website?
You typically cannot price lower on Amazon than on your own site per most retailer agreements, but you can price the same. Factor in Amazon's 15% referral fee and FBA fulfillment costs when calculating your effective margin on that channel.
What is minimum advertised price (MAP) and do I need it?
MAP is the lowest price retailers are allowed to advertise your product. It protects your brand value and prevents price wars between your retail accounts. Set a MAP policy before you have multiple retail accounts — it is much harder to enforce retroactively.
Apply This in Your Checklist