Best Payment Processor for E-Commerce & Online Stores: Stripe, Square, or PayPal?
Every dollar you earn from your online store, whether it’s on Shopify, Etsy, Amazon, or a custom site, needs a payment processor. Fees, payout times, and fraud protection vary a lot between Stripe, Square, and PayPal. Picking the wrong one can cost your e-commerce business real money as your sales grow. Here is a clear comparison for online sellers like you.
READY TO TAKE ACTION?
Use the free LaunchAdvisor checklist to track every step in this guide.
The quick answer
Use Stripe if you are building a dedicated e-commerce store (like on Shopify or WooCommerce), selling digital products, or running a subscription box service that needs flexible online payments and strong APIs. Choose Square if you run an online store but also do in-person sales at craft fairs, pop-up shops, or local pickups, as it combines a POS system with online payments. Add PayPal as a secondary payment option on any e-commerce site where customers expect to see its button for quick checkout.
Side-by-side breakdown
Stripe is built for online transactions. Its tools are powerful for custom checkout flows on your website, managing subscription box billing, and handling international online sales. Standard fees for card transactions are 2.9% + 30 cents, common for online stores. There are no monthly fees. Payouts usually happen in 2 business days, which helps with cash flow for new online businesses.
Square is known for its in-person payment tools but also offers online selling features. Its free POS app and card readers are perfect if you're an Etsy seller doing weekend markets or an online shop offering local pickup. For online sales, Square's fees are similar to Stripe at 2.9% + 30 cents. In-person payments using a Square Reader are 2.6% + 10 cents. It's great for online businesses that have a physical component.
PayPal is one of the most recognized payment options globally, making it a trusted button for online shoppers. Many customers specifically look for the 'Pay with PayPal' option on e-commerce sites. Fees are higher: 3.49% + 49 cents for standard online transactions, and 2.99% + 49 cents for PayPal Checkout. New online sellers, especially those with dropshipping models or high-value items, should be aware that PayPal sometimes places holds on funds, which can delay access to your money.
When to choose Stripe
Stripe is the top choice for online-first businesses that need control and flexibility. If you are launching a Shopify store (using Shopify Payments, which is powered by Stripe and eliminates extra transaction fees), building a custom e-commerce site with WooCommerce, selling online courses, or running a digital product marketplace, Stripe's API and dashboard are unmatched. Even if you're not tech-savvy, Stripe offers easy no-code tools like Payment Links and hosted checkout pages for selling directly from social media or email campaigns.
When to choose Square
Choose Square when your online business also involves selling face-to-face. This is ideal for Etsy sellers attending craft fairs, online boutiques that offer local pickup, or Amazon resellers who operate a small physical showroom. Square's free card reader, integrated POS app, and inventory management system can connect your online and in-person sales seamlessly. While it handles online payments effectively, its real strength lies in providing a unified system for a hybrid online and physical selling model.
When to choose PayPal
You should always add PayPal as a checkout option alongside your primary payment processor, especially for any e-commerce business. A large percentage of online buyers specifically want to use PayPal, and many will abandon their shopping carts if it's not offered. Use it as a supplemental option to increase conversions and customer trust on your Shopify, Etsy, or custom store, rather than as your sole primary processor. Its fee structure can be less predictable and new accounts may face fund holds, which are important considerations for online sellers managing cash flow.
The verdict
For a pure online e-commerce business (like a Shopify store or a custom website selling products or services), Stripe is generally the best primary choice. If your business combines online sales with in-person events like pop-ups or markets (such as an Etsy seller doing craft shows), Square offers a great all-in-one solution. Regardless of your primary processor, always include PayPal as a trusted secondary checkout option on your online store to prevent cart abandonment and build customer trust. If you're on Shopify, Shopify Payments (powered by Stripe) is the obvious and most integrated choice, eliminating transaction fees for using an external gateway.
How to get started
For Stripe, create an account and easily link it to your Shopify, WooCommerce, or BigCommerce store. You can also generate a payment link in minutes for quick sales of digital products or services directly from a social media post. For Square, set up your free online store or order a free Square card reader and install the POS app if you plan to sell in person. All three platforms offer quick account approval for most e-commerce businesses, allowing you to start accepting online payments fast.
RECOMMENDED TOOLS
Stripe
Developer-friendly payments for online businesses — APIs and no-code tools
Square
POS and payments for physical and in-person businesses
Some links above are affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you sign up — at no extra cost to you.
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
Which payment processor has the lowest fees?
At standard rates, Stripe and Square are comparable for most transaction sizes. Square is slightly cheaper for in-person swipes (2.6% + 10 cents vs 2.7% for Stripe Terminal). For high-volume businesses, all three processors offer custom negotiated rates above certain thresholds.
Does PayPal hold funds?
PayPal can place holds on funds for new accounts or accounts flagged for unusual activity. Stripe and Square have more predictable 2-day payout schedules. For primary processing, predictable payouts matter — use Stripe or Square as your main processor.
Can I use multiple payment processors?
Yes. Many businesses use Stripe for online payments and Square for in-person, with PayPal as a supplemental checkout option. Each has a separate dashboard but they operate independently without conflict.
Apply This in Your Checklist